Markandey
Revisiting Roe vs Wade
Markandey Katju 12 May 2022

A controversy is raging in America over Justice Alito's leaked draft judgment proposing to overturn the US Supreme Court's verdict in Roe vs Wade delivered in 1973 regarding the right of abortion.It is believed 4 other judges in the court intend to concur with Justice Alito, making it a majority judgment.

I believe Justice Alito's view is correct,and would like to give my reasons. Of course it is only a draft opinion, but knowing the judicial philosophy of the majority judges it is highly likely it will be confirmed in the final verdict.

In Roe vs Wade the US Supreme Court set up a trimester system of pregnancy in women. In the first trimester ( the first 3 months of pregnancy ) no restrictions could be placed on a woman to abort. In the second trimester, too, abortion was permissible, though the state could put some restrictions e.g. it should be done by qualified medical personnel, in licensed clinics, etc.In the third trimester no abortion was permissible unless a qualified doctor certified that the life of the woman would be in danger without abortion.

In Planned Parenthood vs Casey, 1992, the right to abortion enunciated in Roe was accepted, but the trimester system was replaced by the viability test ( i.e. at what stage of the pregnancy would the foetus be able to survive outside the woman's womb ), and the undue burden test ( i.e. does the restriction on abortion place an undue burden on the pregnant woman e.g. taking the husband's consent ).

I am not going into the questions as to when does life begin, when is a foetus viable, what are undue burdens, etc. My simple point is that under the separation of powers theory ( that each of the 3 organs of the state have their own spheres of operation and should not encroach into each other's domains ), it is for the legislature, not the judiciary, to make laws, and both Roe vs Wade as well as Planned Parenthood vs Casey made laws.

I am personally in favour of the right to abortion, but then this right should be enacted by the legislature, not created by judges. There is nothing specific in the US Constitution which gives a right to abortion. Some states in America have enacted this right, but others have not.

The rights of people in the US Constitution are mentioned in the Bill of Rights and several Amendments to the Constitution, e.g. the 14th Amendment, but the right to abortion is nowhere contained therein.

Of course there is a theory of 'unenumerated rights', i.e. there are some rights which though not expressly mentioned in the Constitution can be said to be part of it, but I do not subscribe to this view. To accept it would mean that any judge, according to his whim and fancy, can declare anything as an 'unenumerated right' and enforce it. This would lead to chaos.

In his book, ' The Nature of the Judicial Process ' Justice Cardozo of the US Supreme Court observed " A judge is not a Knight Errant roaming at will in pursuit of his own ideal of beauty and goodness ".

In his dissenting judgment in Griswold vs Connecticut, Justice Hugo Black warned that ' unbounded judicial creativity will make this Court a day to day National Convention '.

In Lochner vs New York the celebrated Justice Holmes of the US Supreme Court in his dissenting judgment criticised the majority of the court for becoming a super legislature by inventing a 'liberty of contract' theory thereby enforcing its particular laissez faire economic philosophy.

The job of a judge is to interpret the law made by the legislature, and apply it to specific cases, but not to make law. Roe vs Wade ( and Planned Parenthood vs Casey ) clearly made law, which was the function of the legislature. Hence it should be reversed.

By Justice Markandey Katju, Former Judge, Supreme Court of India

Did you find this write up useful? YES 0 NO 0
Biff Cottrill   21 Jul 2024 12:39am
ASSET RECLAIM IS POSSIBLE WITH THE RIGHT FIRM: There is a glimmer of hope through ICC RECOVERY SERVICE, and I am voluntarily publishing this review so read more
Reply
Martin Jungwirth   10 Jul 2024 8:17pm
With an amazing experience, I can't help but talk enough about Elite web Recovery services. Sometimes on June 19, an intruder managed to get into my email read more
Reply
Barry Clemens   5 Jul 2024 12:07am
RETRIEVE YOUR STOLEN CRYPTO,BTC,ETH WITH CYBERETRIEVE Before I found this specific recovery company,I was on the verge of concluding that everyone in read more
Reply
Marry J   4 Jul 2024 3:08pm
As with all the other investors scammed I started small with £100 that showed a good return. They moved £100 back to my bank account to show how fast read more
Reply
Anna   28 Jun 2024 9:08pm
The need to spying and accessing phones informations remotely may be considered a last resort. Example, ways for knowing if a partner is cheating is having read more
Reply
Penuel   28 Apr 2024 9:51pm
So much to write about hackerone975 @ gm ail c om which if I start I will cover the whole internet with the good jobs this hacker has done for me so far read more
Reply
Maria Rodriguez   28 Apr 2024 9:51pm
I suspected my husband of cheating on me, and reaching to this hackerone975 at gm ail c om ,helped me discover the truth. I could monitor her phone remotely read more
Reply
Linda   27 Apr 2024 3:11pm
I DEPOSITED BITCOIN IN A TRADING WEBSITE ,THEN I WANTED TO SELL AND WITHDRAW MY FUNDS AND PROFIT FROM THEM, I HAVE MAILED AND MESSAGED THEM, BUT NO RESPONSE.. read more
Reply
Victoria   27 Apr 2024 3:10pm
I lost all my savings to CM Trading. I invested 41,000 and they refused to allow me to withdraw both my initial deposit and accrued interest. I have reached read more
Reply
Doug Hale   16 Apr 2024 6:45pm
Hi everyone. I want to share with you all how Elite Web Recovery played a crucial role in recovering my stolen Bitcoin after falling victim to a phishing read more
Reply
Doug Hale   16 Apr 2024 6:40pm
Hi everyone. I want to share with you all how Elite Web Recovery played a crucial role in recovering my stolen Bitcoin after falling victim to a phishing read more
Reply
Arthur Bill   15 Mar 2024 1:22pm
I am Arthur Bill, and I want to share my experience with Elite Web Recovery in recovering my stolen funds. When I discovered that my funds had been stolen read more
Reply
Karen Sturgill   3 Feb 2024 10:43pm
Greetings everyone, I want y'all to be careful with cryptocurrency scams. In recent years, the world of cryptocurrency has experienced a surge in scams read more
Reply
Ethan Lucas   10 Jan 2024 9:36am
Hello everyone. My name is Ethan Lucas, and I live in Calgary, Canada. I lost a lot of money to a cryptocurrency investment fraud once. I made an investment read more
Reply
Jean Melson   24 Dec 2023 1:24am
A few months ago I made a terrible mistake that caused me to lose around $110,000 on a fake crypto investment trading platform. They tricked me into investing read more
Reply
Lori Parker   21 Dec 2023 5:23pm
I was one of the victims of a crypto investment scam that saw me lose $302,000 worth of crypto. The crypto market is very volatile and a lot of individuals read more
Reply
Lori Parker   21 Dec 2023 5:23pm
I was one of the victims of a crypto investment scam that saw me lose $302,000 worth of crypto. The crypto market is very volatile and a lot of individuals read more
Reply
Chase Parton   14 Dec 2023 2:53am
Telegram is a wild place and full of scammers, i was a victim of cryptocurrency scammers and lost a considerable amount of bitcoins. There was someone read more
Reply
Sean Clara   15 Nov 2023 1:18pm
SCRIPTHACKERS FOR HIRE Require services of a certified and experienced ethical hacker for your general ethical and specialized Hacks? + Access various read more
Reply
Sarah   18 Oct 2023 11:02am
To many unsuspecting victims of online crypto investment fraud just like me who only wanted to make an extra income aside our daily jobs by doing something read more
Reply
Glenn   12 Oct 2023 5:42pm
I never thought I would ever be a victim of investment fraud only to be convinced to part with $200 investment to start. It was so smooth and friendly read more
Reply
Mabel   15 Aug 2023 9:13am
They render genuine services to individuals world wide, they are more secured group of people in Netherland, who deal with cyber issues of all kind of read more
Reply
rose   22 Apr 2023 8:28am
Hacking a mobile phone is usually something that requires hiring an expert to get it done for you to get your desired result. These mobile hacks actually read more
Reply
Sandra Rivers   15 Dec 2022 2:40am
HIRE A CERTIFIED AND GUARANTEED CRYPTO RECOVERY AND PHONE SPYING EXPERT AT REMOTESPYTECH Finding out that your husband or wife has been unfaithful isn’t read more
Reply
Mat Toney  21 Jul 2022 6:30am
Have you ever thought of recovering your bitcoin from bogus trading platforms? Perhaps recover the bitcoin you sent to a scammer? I bet you are not alone. read more
Reply
×

C2RMTo Know More

Something Awesome Is In The Work

0

DAYS

0

HOURS

0

MINUTES

0

SECONDS

Sign-up and we will notify you of our launch.
We’ll also give some discount for your effort :)

* We won’t use your email for spam, just to notify you of our launch.
×

SAARTHTo Know More

Launching Soon : SAARTH, your complete client, case, practise & document management SAAS application with direct client chat feature.

If you want to know more give us a Call at :+91 98109 29455 or Mail info@soolegal.com