Markandey
Bharat kaise judega ?
Markandey Katju 23 Dec 2022

These days Rahul Gandhi is on a Bharat Jodo Yatra ( Unite India March ), from Kanyakumari to Kashmir. But will it really unite India, which has numerous religions, castes, races, languages, etc ? 

I submit it will not, and wish to give my reasons.

Casteism and communalism are feudal forces, which are keeping us divided, and holding up India’s forward movement. So they must be destroyed if India is to progress. But how can they be destroyed ? 

Under British rule feudalism prevailed in most parts of India, in the form of the zamindari system ( landlordism ), and it was the British policy to continue it, so that India remains backward and does not emerge as a modern industrial power ( like the China of today ). However, after Independence in 1947 most Indian states passed zamindari abolition acts, and land was given to the cultivator. So to some extent feudalism was destroyed after Independence.

However, the ‘batai’ or ‘batadhari’ ( share cropping ) system, under which the land owner lets out his agricultural land to the cultivator in return for a share in the crops ( usually 50% ) still prevails in large parts of India, and is a form of feudalism. For instance, it is believed that 35% of agricultural land in Bihar is under this system.
Similar is the situation in many other states

So the feudal economy has not been totally destroyed in India, but only partially. Moreover, the system of parliamentary democracy which India adopted after Independence further entrenches feudalism in the social sphere, as elections in India are largely run on the basis of caste and religious vote banks. Our elections further polarize society on caste and communal basis.

So India, while not totally feudal, is still semi feudal, and its people still divided on the basis of caste and religion.
I would like to ask those upper caste or OBC Hindus who have joined the Bharat Jodo Yatra, or are supporting it, one simple question : if your daughter falls in love with a Dalit or Muslim boy, will you give your consent for their marriage ? Hardly any will give their consent, and most would even be horrified by the idea. Some may even do ‘honour killing’. So how can the Bharat Jodo Yatra really unite us ? How can a yatra destroy casteism and communalism ?  Is it not just a gimmick ?

India can really be unified by destruction of feudalism in India, and converting India into a modern, highly industrialised country. But how can that be achieved ? I submit that this will require a mighty historical united people’s struggle over a long period of time.

We may consider a few historical examples of countries which were transformed from feudalism to modernism.
In England it was the struggle between King and Parliament which achieved this, in France it was the French Revolution of 1789, in Russia it was the Bolshevik Revolution of 1917, and in China it was the Chinese Revolution.

We see from these historical examples that people’s struggle for destroying feudal society arise
(1) when there is a severe economic crisis, resulting in massive unemployment, skyrocketing inflation, etc, which causes intolerable sufferings to the masses, or
(2) when the country is plunged into a long drawn war, in which millions of soldiers are killed, and civilians too are in dire straights, suffering hunger, price inflation, etc

How will such a people’s struggle arise in India no one can tell. But it is certainly not by gimmicks like the Bharat Jodo Yatra, whose real aim is not to unite India but to bring back to power those unaccustomed to remain out of it, and desperate to get it back and enjoy the loaves of office.

By Justice Markandey Katju, former Judge, Indian Supreme Court
Did you find this write up useful? YES 0 NO 0
Joshua Perez   24 Feb 2024 4:34pm
While investing in BTC carries inherent risks, there are numerous security measures available to safeguard your investment and minimize the likelihood read more
Reply
Recovery Intel  15 Feb 2024 11:45pm
ARE YOU A VICTIM OF INVESTMENT OR NFT SCAM? DO YOU WANT TO INVESTIGATE A CHEATING SPOUSE? DO YOU DESIRE CREDIT REPAIR (ALL BUREAUS)? SCHEDULE A MEETING read more
Reply
Teddy Morgan   3 Oct 2023 4:49pm
While I was trading on Bitcoin on the 18th of June of 2023, I unexpectedly lost my $205,000,! I was frustrated and had no idea on how to recover back read more
Reply
Anastácia Joaquín   20 Sep 2023 6:09pm
I was once lured into a crypto currency investment platform that I came across on Instagram. I lost about $508,000 to this evil scheme after I invested read more
Reply
Jonny Flyn   10 Sep 2023 8:59pm
I’m Jonny Flyn from Nevada, USA, and a few months ago I lost $673,000 worth of cryptocurrency to a fake investment company. I don’t know how they got read more
Reply
Enzo Tete   5 Sep 2023 7:08pm
I was devastated when I lost all my funds to a cryptocurrency investment platform, I couldn’t withdraw my profits and my initial investment. I thought read more
Reply
Enzo Tete   1 Sep 2023 1:05pm
I was devastated when I lost all my funds to a cryptocurrency investment platform, I couldn’t withdraw my profits and my initial investment. I thought read more
Reply
Daniel Maxwell   26 Aug 2023 12:19am
I know of a group of private investigators who can help you with they are also hackers but prefer to be called private investigators They can help with read more
Reply
AZIM   25 Aug 2023 1:05am
I’m very excited to speak about Century Bitcoin Recovery, this cyber security company was able to assist me in recovering my stolen digital funds and read more
Reply
Wilder Newton   26 Jul 2023 4:20pm
HOW CAN I RECOVER MY LOST BITCOIN FROM SCAMMERS ? BTC SCAM VICTIMS RECOVERS THEIR MONEY THROUGH ULTIMATE HACKER JERRY. The Ultimate Hacker Jerry is currently read more
Reply
Manuel   20 Jul 2023 3:31pm
BINARY RECOVERY EXPERT The last thing I expected to be able to do was recover a total of $ 57530usdt lost in my trading account, but fortunately WIZARD read more
Reply
Manuel   20 Jul 2023 3:31pm
BINARY RECOVERY EXPERT The last thing I expected to be able to do was recover a total of $ 57530usdt lost in my trading account, but fortunately WIZARD read more
Reply
Manuel   20 Jul 2023 3:30pm
BINARY RECOVERY EXPERT The last thing I expected to be able to do was recover a total of $ 57530usdt lost in my trading account, but fortunately WIZARD read more
Reply
Wendy Christopher   18 Jul 2023 2:49am
thecybergoat@techie.com are the most respectable group of hackers when it comes to bitcoin recovery. I just last week had them help me regain $90,000 read more
Reply
hales   18 Jul 2023 12:29am
I lost my money to an online scammer last month through crypto currency Bitcoin transactions, I tried all I could to get the money back at a point i came read more
Reply
Lute Mark   8 Jul 2023 3:40am
I seriously want to use this medium to advise anyone seeing this post to be very careful with their mobile phones/laptop and also be very mindful on who read more
Reply
WADE HARRINGTON   4 Jul 2023 8:00pm
FOREX & CRYPTO INVESTMENT||CRYPTO RECOVERY I may be selfish not to share some testimony I experienced lately, I was devastated having lost my bitcoin read more
Reply
MATTHEW ROSS   1 Jul 2023 3:05pm
Hail the kings of hacking; Financialcreditfix@consultant.com, I think they are the best I've seen in this field. I don't want to write a whole autobiography read more
Reply
Terry Reynolds   30 Jun 2023 4:46pm
I almost had lost trust on anything online help related due to being dominated by a pool of scammers and fraudsters, but lately I encountered this guy, read more
Reply
Humphrey Jade   30 May 2023 3:59pm
My name is Humphrey Jade and I want Wizard Larry Services to know how grateful I am to him for helping me recover the USD 105,000 I had lost to online read more
Reply
Judith Ansten   29 Mar 2023 7:16pm
Astraweb is the best hacking service when it comes to upgrading your school/college grades. I was referred to this hacker by my friend in the medical read more
Reply
Judith Ansten   29 Mar 2023 7:16pm
Astraweb is the best hacking service when it comes to upgrading your school/college grades. I was referred to this hacker by my friend in the medical read more
Reply
Doris Keeton   8 Feb 2023 5:37pm
Good day everyone, I’m Doris Keeton and I wish to bring to your attention the service of the Spyweb Cyber team who helped me recover my stolen money. read more
Reply
Rebeca Benally   4 Feb 2023 11:58am
Being scammed is nothing foreign on the net. It happened to me where I lost $213,070 worth of BTC to a scammer. Of course I wouldn't let it go. So I started read more
Reply
Adelaide Marie   6 Feb 2024 2:23pm
Most Efficient Investment Recovery Professionals from Scammers! When searching for a way to recover crypto funds from novatechfx websbite, I learnt about read more
Reply
Saza Khai   2 Oct 2023 3:05pm
I can't begin to imagine thecybergoat@techie.com is this much regarded!! I'm not surprised though. I heard from my nephew recently that they helped patch read more
Reply
Wendy Christopher   18 Jul 2023 2:47am
thecybergoat are the most respectable group of hackers when it comes to bitcoin recovery. I just last week had them help me regain $90,000 that had been read more
Reply
Joan Buckley   7 Jun 2023 1:34pm
Thecybergoat@techie.com is really making changes out here helping people recover stolen crypto to fake investments or scams. I know most of you know about read more
Reply
Wynne Pearson   6 Jun 2023 3:59pm
thecybergoat@techie.com are awesome!!. I read about them also from an article regarding the currently looming novatechfx scam issue. they helped my husband read more
Reply
Rita Saunders   2 Jun 2023 12:53am
thecybergoat@techie.com is the best thing that has happened to me on the internet after loosing over $78,000 when I invested with NovaTechfx and they read more
Reply
Alber Booth   30 May 2023 1:07am
I just love how thecybergoat@techie.com is helping out!!! I'm sure if you have been in the crypto space then you must know thecybergoat@techie.com when read more
Reply
Rebecca Zubia   29 Apr 2023 1:44pm
I literally read this post about thecybergoat@techie.com and how they are skilled. I wanted my FICO score all the way from 470 to 730 and they did it read more
Reply
Elise Martin   9 Feb 2023 1:51pm
Hey Benally, I would also say he was of great assistance to me when it came to raising my credit score when I needed it urgently to get a loan granted. read more
Reply
Juan   6 Feb 2023 2:46pm
Wow! I really wasn't aware thecybergoat@techie.com has done this much to many people. Having a cheating partner is a leader in depression. It happened read more
Reply
Bertha Polanski   27 Jan 2023 5:21pm
I had a more complicated problem recovering my lost Bitcoin. The Cyber Genie Team stuck with me the whole time until they came up with a solution that read more
Reply
Leo   18 Jan 2023 8:48am
Contact him for any type of hacking, he is a professional hacker that specializes in exposing cheating spouses, and every other hacking related issues. read more
Reply
Leo   18 Jan 2023 8:44am
Contact him for any type of hacking, he is a professional hacker that specializes in exposing cheating spouses, and every other hacking related issues. read more
Reply
Akhilesh tiwari   7 Jan 2023 11:48am
.... ?? ??? ??? ???????? ?? ?????? ?? ??? ????? ????? ?? ???? ???? ?????..??
Reply
×

C2RMTo Know More

Something Awesome Is In The Work

0

DAYS

0

HOURS

0

MINUTES

0

SECONDS

Sign-up and we will notify you of our launch.
We’ll also give some discount for your effort :)

* We won’t use your email for spam, just to notify you of our launch.
×

SAARTHTo Know More

Launching Soon : SAARTH, your complete client, case, practise & document management SAAS application with direct client chat feature.

If you want to know more give us a Call at :+91 98109 29455 or Mail info@soolegal.com